Mill Creek plays over some of the highest terrain in Monroe County, with views of the Rochester skyline and of the hills of the Finger Lakes region to the south. Two courses are part of this club.

The Championship course was designed by Ray Hearn and Paul Albanese, and opened in 2004. The standard walking rates are $29 weekdays and $39 weekends, while the riding rates are $39 and $49, respectively. Twilight, senior, and junior discounts are available.

The 9-hole Executive course is a Rick Jacobsen design that debuted in 2000 and plays from 815 to 1,335 yards. The walking rates are $10 for nine and $16 for eighteen holes; carts are $10.